Is Michelle Pfeiffer Set to Fill Kevin Costner’s Yellowstone Shoes?

Kevin Costner’s wavering return to Yellowstone has kept fans guessing, but now attention shifts to a potential spin-off, and the rumored star is none other than Michelle Pfeiffer. Reports suggest Pfeiffer could headline Taylor Sheridan’s new series, tentatively titled 2024, amid uncertainties surrounding Matthew McConaughey’s involvement due to alleged salary disputes.

According to Daily Caller, industry insiders hint at Pfeiffer’s possible casting, indicating a strategic shift towards embracing “girl power” and contemporary themes in the Yellowstone franchise. This move aligns with industry trends as studios navigate post-pandemic constraints and budget pressures.


While McConaughey’s hesitation may pave the way for Pfeiffer’s lead role, Costner’s return remains uncertain, possibly limited to a cameo appearance. The potential casting of Pfeiffer signals a significant opportunity for the acclaimed actress, described as “excited and ready to go” by insiders close to the production.

For Pfeiffer, this role represents a long-awaited opportunity, contrasting with the indecisiveness of her male counterparts. However, McConaughey’s delay could prove costly, jeopardizing his involvement in the franchise. Despite the potential gains for Pfeiffer, Costner and McConaughey’s uncertain status reflects the challenging landscape of the Yellowstone ranch.

As speculation swirls around the Yellowstone spin-off, Pfeiffer’s potential casting promises a fresh perspective, infusing new energy into the beloved series.

Joanne Wells

Joanne Wells is a media journalist for ScreenNearYou. She reports on the inside conversations in Hollywood. Also, she loves pizza!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. (required)