Netflix’s latest docuseries, “Depp v. Heard,” delves into the highly publicized defamation trial involving Johnny Depp and Amber Heard, along with the subsequent social media frenzy. However, the series has drawn criticism for its tactless approach and lack of substantive analysis.
Director Emma Cooper stitches together a collection of YouTube commentary, TikTok memes, and news coverage to present various perspectives on the trial. The intention is less about drawing conclusions regarding the truthfulness of either party’s claims and more about exploring the implications of the case in a post-#MeToo culture.
The initial episodes of Depp v. Heard seems to indicate a focus on the role of social media in shaping public opinion and potentially influencing jurors. It addresses the misogynistic undertones that led to a massive online harassment campaign reminiscent of the #GamerGate era.
Yet, as the series progresses, it dedicates a disproportionate amount of screen time to critics of Amber Heard, which appears counterproductive in highlighting the disinformation it seeks to address.
“While the series flirts with an analysis, it’s far too committed to remaining ambiguous for a suspenseful effect and possibly for fear of getting into legal trouble. And that choice serves no one other than the plentifully rewarded,” a critic notes.
The docuseries also covers contentious moments from the trial, such as the dispute over the Milani Cosmetics compact that Heard’s lawyer used to demonstrate how she concealed alleged bruises.
Another instance involves the term “megapint,” referring to the amount of wine Depp poured himself in a video captured by Heard. The series’ incorporation of soap-opera-style music over court footage adds to the overall perception of a shallow treatment of the serious matter at hand.
In essence, “Depp v. Heard” appears more focused on providing a sensationalized recap of the trial rather than offering a nuanced analysis of the larger issues surrounding domestic abuse allegations and the influence of social media.
