Why Did Piers Morgan Criticize Netflix Over ‘Baby Reindeer’?

In a recent turn of events, Piers Morgan has openly criticized Netflix for its handling of identities and stories in the controversial show “Baby Reindeer.” The journalist has voiced his concerns following a revealing interview with Fiona Harvey, the real-life counterpart to the show’s central character, who claims her life has been negatively impacted by the portrayal.

Piers Morgan Calls for Transparency and Accountability

During his appearance on ITV’s “Lorraine,” Morgan discussed his interaction with Fiona Harvey, who expressed her distress over how her identity was handled by Netflix and Richard Gadd, the creator of “Baby Reindeer.” Harvey, feeling misrepresented, has announced her intentions to take legal action against both Gadd and Netflix.

Adding to the intrigue, Morgan has extended an invitation to Richard Gadd to appear on his show “Uncensored” to provide his side of the story and the “evidence” of the events depicted in the series. Morgan believes that Gadd has a responsibility to address these claims, especially considering the complexities of the human interest story at the heart of the series.

Baby Reindeer

Netflix Criticized for Failing Duty of Care

Morgan’s critique of Netflix centres on the streaming giant’s failure to protect Fiona Harvey’s identity, potentially leading to severe personal repercussions for Harvey. “Netflix, in particular, has failed in their duty of care to Fiona Harvey,” Morgan told Lorraine.

He praised Gadd’s storytelling prowess but questioned the ethical implications of turning such sensitive real-life stories into entertainment without robust evidence and consideration for the involved parties.

The Financial and Emotional Toll on Fiona Harvey

Fiona Harvey herself has spoken out about the profound impact the show has had on her life, describing the experience as “obscene” and “misogynistic.” She has faced severe backlash and even death threats, which have deterred her from watching the series.

Harvey’s demands for a £1 million payment for her interview with Morgan underline her intent to regain control over her narrative and seek reparations for her portrayal.

Richard Gadd’s Response

In contrast, Richard Gadd has opted to step back from the ongoing public discourse, suggesting that “Baby Reindeer” should be viewed purely as a piece of art. He expressed his desire to avoid the “whack-a-mole” game of continuously responding to public and media inquiries, emphasizing the semi-fictional nature of the show despite its basis in real events.

This situation highlights the delicate balance between artistic expression and ethical responsibility in media productions. As the conversation unfolds, it becomes increasingly clear that the lines between art and real-life implications are often blurred, prompting a broader discussion about the responsibilities of content creators and platforms like Netflix.

Joanne Wells

Joanne Wells is a media journalist for ScreenNearYou. She reports on the inside conversations in Hollywood. Also, she loves pizza!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. (required)