As the chilling anthology series, American Horror Story, embarks on its journey into its 12th season on Hulu and FX, the haunting echoes of previous seasons continue to linger in the minds of its dedicated audience. Throughout its illustrious run, AHS has ventured into realms of fear, terror, and horror that have sent shivers down the spines of viewers. With each season delving into a unique storyline, genre, and subgenre of horror, there’s a frightful experience for every kind of fear-seeker. And in the midst of anticipation for the next season, we’re daring to rank these bone-chilling seasons by their fear factor and the overall quality of their eerie narratives, revealing the most scariest American Horror Story Seasons that left an indelible mark and the few that didn’t quite hit the mark in the AHS saga.
Where to watch American Horror Story?
Fans of American Horror Story can dive into the horror anthology’s 12 seasons on Hulu, where a nightmarish journey awaits with a variety of spine-tingling tales. Moreover, for those who have yet to experience the hair-raising thrill of this series, 10 seasons of American Horror Story are also available for streaming on Prime Video in the US. Whether you’re seeking to revisit your favourite chilling moments or embark on a fresh journey into the realms of the supernatural, these streaming platforms offer a passport to a world of fear and terror crafted by the minds behind AHS. Moreover, you can also avail Hulu free trial in the US, if you wish to explore through the platform and discover a variety of TV shows and movies available.
How are the scariest American Horror Story Seasons ranked?
Ranked from lowest to highest according to Rotten Tomatoes, we’ve scrutinized the scariest seasons of American Horror Story. This gripping anthology series has invited viewers into some of the most nightmarish tales ever portrayed on screen, from sinister asylums to haunted hotels, and beyond. Each season presents a distinctive mix of different horror styles, making it a quintessential representation of all things eerie. It fearlessly explores the realms of terror while keeping viewers engaged with its talented cast that changes from season to season. Furthermore, you can also watch American Horror Story: Delicate Season 12 outside USA on FXX, by following some very basic guidelines.
#11 AHS: Hotel (Season 5, 2015)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 64%
American Horror Story: Hotel from Season 5 takes viewers on a dark and thrilling journey. While it adheres to the classic American Horror Story formula, it’s notable for the captivating lead performance by singer-turned-actor Lady Gaga as The Countess. Her presence elevates the LGBTQ+ friendly show to new heights. Set in the eerie Hotel Cortez, inspired by the infamous Cecil Hotel, the season delves into a murder investigation that unveils a history steeped in violence and mystery. Despite being one of the lowest-rated seasons, “Hotel” still offers a chilling and engaging experience filled with twists and spooky moments. You can watch this season on Hulu platform. Moreover, you can check out some of the best shows on Hulu, if you subscribe to the platform.
#10 AHS: NYC (Season 11, 2022)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 71%
Season 11, titled American Horror Story: NYC, explores the vibrant yet complex LGBTQ+ culture in 1980s New York City. This season serves as a daring and thought-provoking reflection on sociocultural issues. It dives deep into themes of identity, nostalgia, and unrest. By using erotica and taboo subjects, “NYC” unfolds a unique narrative that revolves entirely around the LGBTQ+ community, making it one of the most socially significant seasons in the series.
You might also like: What To Expect From American Horror Stories: Huluween Event?
#09 AHS: Murder House (Season 1, 2011)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 72%
Murder House marked the beginning of the American Horror Story saga. This season is set in a haunted suburban house in Los Angeles, which becomes the backdrop for a chilling exploration of vengeful spirits and their impact on the lives of the house’s new occupants. Murder House introduced audiences to the gripping, eerie stories that would become a hallmark of the series.
#08 AHS: Cult (Season 7, 2017)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 73%
American Horror Story: Cult takes a bold step into modern political chaos, directly addressing the aftermath of the 2016 election. It follows two primary characters, Ally and Kai, each navigating the volatile landscape in their own way. The performance of Sarah Paulson as Ally, coupled with Evan Peters’ portrayal of Kai, adds undeniable depth to the season, although it may polarize viewers due to its politically charged themes.
#07 AHS: Roanoke (Season 6, 2016)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 74%
Season 6, Roanoke, embraced unconventional storytelling methods by blending documentary-style narratives with found footage techniques. It begins with “My Roanoke Nightmare,” a documentary-style format that gradually shifts into a found footage style as characters try to create a sequel. This approach allows “Roanoke” to explore the evolution of tragedy into myth and the blurred lines between reality and entertainment.
#06 AHS: Freak Show (Season 4, 2014)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 77%
American Horror Story: Freak Show transports viewers to a 1950s Florida carnival, focusing on the lives of the carnival’s unique inhabitants. This season weaves a tale of underdogs struggling to survive in a changing world. The cast’s exceptional performances, coupled with the memorable character Twisty The Clown, create one of the most endearing seasons in the series, combining horror with the magic of the carnival.
#05 AHS: Apocalypse (Season 8, 2018)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 79%
Apocalypse brings a novel twist to American Horror Story by serving as a sequel/crossover to previous seasons, including Murder House, Coven, and Hotel. This season explores the consequences of the antichrist’s birth and the chaos following a nuclear attack. It introduces a wide array of supernatural elements, featuring witches, psychopaths, and demons. While it may be an intense season, it’s a rewarding watch for hardcore fans of the series. Moreover, if you are into horror genre, be sure to checkout some of the best horror movies on Peacock TV, that will surely make your evenings spooky!
#04 AHS: Double Feature (Season 10, 2021)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 80%
Double Feature introduces a unique format, telling two interwoven stories, “Red Tide” and “Death Valley.” This season capitalizes on themes of regret, choices, and the horrors that ensue when people venture into the unknown. “Red Tide” immerses viewers in a chilling beach town, while “Death Valley” takes them on a nightmarish journey with a group of college students. The season’s success lies in its thematic interaction, providing a refreshing and suspenseful viewing experience.
#03 AHS: Asylum (Season 2 , 2012)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 84%
American Horror Story: Asylum takes place in the 1960s and unfolds within the confines of Briarcliff Manor, a mental institution rife with dark secrets. The narrative kicks off when a reporter is wrongfully institutionalized, exposing her to the horrors lurking within the asylum. This season marks a turning point for the series, featuring Jessica Lange’s iconic performance and a storyline that boldly ventures into disturbing territory.
#02 AHS: Coven (Season 3, 2013)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 85%
Coven offers a deep dive into the world of witches in New Orleans, mixing modern-day and historical elements. This season boasts an ensemble cast that includes Jessica Lange, Sarah Paulson, Frances Conroy, and more, making it a fan-favorite. The season captures the essence of witchcraft and its entwined history, from the Salem Witch Trials to contemporary times, delivering an unforgettable viewing experience.
#01 AHS: 1984 (Season 9, 2019)
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 88%
1984 distinguishes itself as a thrilling and nostalgic homage to the 1980s slasher movie genre. The story is set against the backdrop of the summer of 1984 at Camp Redwood, unfolding a classic horror scenario where the camp counsellors find themselves hunted by relentless adversaries. This season expertly captures the essence of iconic 1980s horror classics such as Friday The 13th. It effectively infuses the series with a delightful blend of campy slasher tropes. As the season unfolds, it delivers a riveting and exhilarating experience that masterfully blends suspense with a profound sense of nostalgia, making it a standout entry in the American Horror Story series.
Bottom line!
As we journey through the haunting worlds of American Horror Story, it becomes evident that each season, with its distinct brand of horror and storytelling, has something unique to offer. Whether you favour the chilling atmosphere of Hotel, or the spine-tingling moments of Murder House, these seasons have captivated audiences in their own ways. No matter your preference, the diversity of horror in scariest American Horror Story seasons ensures that there’s something for everyone in this enduring and iconic series. Happy Halloween!
